Negotiating Agreement Without Giving in
In this summary, the author addresses three fundamental problems in times when people struggle to negotiate effectively. Firstly, calling the feelings of others useless or rejecting the person in front can lead to even more negative emotions regarding the offer. However, when good relations exist between both parties and they consider each other as partners in conversation rather than competitors, the likelihood of this problem diminishes, and people are more inclined to agree with your point.
This principle holds true for both individuals and larger entities, such as companies and countries. For instance, in negotiations between the United States of America and Mexico, the United States aimed to buy Mexico's natural gas at a lower price, which angered the people of Mexico. Instead of selling the gas, the Mexican government began burning it. This example underscores the importance of understanding the differences in thoughts between parties and seeking mutually beneficial solutions.
To navigate negotiations effectively, it is crucial to identify the difference between your thoughts and the other person's thoughts. Find ways to respect both parties' wishes. Multiple solutions often exist for any given problem, and by considering every possible solution, you can arrive at the best option. Understanding your BATNA (Best Alternative To a Negotiated Agreement) is vital for making informed decisions that avoid significant harm.
Chester L. Karrass famously stated, "In business, you don't get what you deserve; you get what you negotiate." This book, "Getting To Yes," written by Roger Fisher, William Ury, and Bruce Patton, offers a step-by-step method to achieve successful negotiations. Roger Fisher, a Harvard Law School professor, started the Harvard Negotiation Project with his colleagues. William Ury, a renowned anthropologist, works as a peace negotiator for various corporate and government organizations worldwide. Bruce Patton, a lecturer at Harvard University, co-founded Vintage Partners, an international consultancy company that helps improve negotiation skills.
In this summary, we will explore the key concepts from "Getting To Yes" across multiple chapters. Each chapter is essential for understanding how to reach YES in any negotiation.
Chapter 1: Don't Bargain Over Positions
Often, people get stuck in positional bargaining while negotiating a deal. They focus on moving ahead and winning rather than reaching mutual agreements. For example, a buyer bargaining for a lower price in a gift shop might clash with a seller insisting on a regular price. Both parties become adamant, leading to arguments about cost and ultimately spoiling the relationship.
To avoid this, understand that there are two ways to solve the problem: soft bargaining and hard bargaining. Soft negotiators aim for mutual agreements without conflicts, benefiting both parties. They see the other party as a friend and strive to satisfy both sides. In contrast, hard negotiators view the other party as an adversary and push for their terms. If both buyer and seller remain firm, they engage in hard bargaining, which can damage relationships.
In soft negotiations, both parties aim to reach a price acceptable to both. For instance, if a friend is selling a bike for twenty thousand rupees, and you can only spend fifteen thousand, a soft bargain involves explaining your situation and reaching an agreement. This approach helps both parties feel satisfied.
Chapter 2: Steer clear of needless disputes
Arguments often arise when both parties are unwilling to compromise. For example, if two companies are negotiating a deal and neither is willing to bend, it is better to cancel the agreement early rather than engaging in fruitless debates. Unnecessary arguments waste time and energy, and they can strain relationships.
Remember that you are negotiating with human beings who bring their experiences, values, and emotions into the discussion. People may react differently to the same situation, leading to misunderstandings. To avoid this, separate the people from the problem and focus on the issue at hand. The goal of negotiation should be mutual agreement, not victory or defeat.
Chapter 3: Keep People and Issues Separate
When negotiating, it is crucial to separate people from the issues. Focus on solving the problem rather than attacking the person. For example, if you are negotiating child custody after a divorce, avoid discussing the reasons for the breakup and focus on the welfare of the children.
People often take things personally, leading to emotional reactions that can derail negotiations. By keeping issues separate, you can address the problem without harming personal relationships. Understand that emotions play a significant role in negotiations, and be empathetic towards the other party's feelings.
Chapter 4: Focus on Interests, Not Positions
Effective negotiation requires focusing on interests rather than positions. For example, two students arguing about whether to keep a window open or closed were eventually satisfied when a librarian addressed their underlying interests: fresh air and preventing strong winds. By focusing on interests, you can find solutions that satisfy both parties.
In many cases, people have different demands for the same thing. Addressing their fundamental interests rather than their positions can help reach a consensus. Understanding basic human needs, such as security, financial stability, and a sense of belonging, can guide negotiations towards mutually beneficial solutions.
Chapter 5: Find Human Needs
Understanding the basic human needs that motivate everyone can significantly improve the chances of reaching an agreement. For instance, in a divorce case, a wife demanding a high alimony might be seeking financial security. If the husband's income is low, discussing realistic options that meet basic needs can lead to a satisfactory agreement for both parties.
The same principle applies to companies and countries. For example, in negotiations between the United States and Mexico, respecting Mexico's need for fair pricing and dignity could have prevented conflict and led to a successful agreement.
Chapter 6: Know Your BATNA
BATNA, or Best Alternative To a v Agreement, is a crucial concept in negotiation. It represents the best option if the current negotiation fails. Knowing your BATNA gives you leverage and confidence in negotiations. For example, if you are selling a house and the buyer offers a lower price, comparing this offer with your BATNA (e.g., renting out the house) can help you make an informed decision.
Developing a strong BATNA involves identifying and working on realistic alternatives. This preparation strengthens your position and helps you negotiate more effectively.
Chapter 7: Avoid Unnecessary Arguments
Unnecessary arguments often arise when neither party is willing to compromise. In such cases, it is better to end the negotiation early rather than wasting time and energy. Recognize that emotions play a significant role in negotiations, and avoid personal attacks or bitter words.
By focusing on solving the problem rather than winning the argument, you can maintain a positive relationship and find mutually beneficial solutions.
Chapter 8: Develop Multiple Options
When negotiating, consider multiple options rather than getting stuck in a binary yes-or-no situation. Exploring various solutions increases the chances of finding a mutually satisfactory agreement. For example, when planning a family trip, considering both the beach and hill station options can lead to a compromise that satisfies everyone.
In negotiations, look for creative solutions that address the interests of both parties. This approach fosters cooperation and increases the likelihood of reaching an agreement.
Chapter 9: Have Strong Justifications
Ensure that your decisions are backed by strong justifications. Clear and well-explained reasons strengthen your position and make your decisions more acceptable to the other party. For example, when negotiating the price of a flat, having a clear rationale for your offer based on market criteria can help convince the broker.
Strong justifications provide a solid foundation for negotiations and enhance the credibility of your arguments.
Chapter 10: Develop Your BATNA
Developing a strong BATNA involves two steps: making a list of alternatives and working on them to make them realistic. For example, if your company does not promote you, consider options like finding a job in another company, starting your own business, or joining a labor union.
Working on these options gives you a clear understanding of your alternatives and strengthens your negotiation position. A strong BATNA provides leverage and flexibility, allowing you to negotiate from a position of strength.
In summary, effective negotiation requires understanding the differences in thoughts and interests between parties, respecting both parties' wishes, and developing a strong BATNA. By focusing on interests rather than positions, separating people from issues, and avoiding unnecessary arguments, you can navigate negotiations successfully. Developing multiple options and having strong justifications further enhance your negotiation skills.
コメント